Choosing the right digital marketing agency can be the difference between watching your brand grow—or watching your budget disappear with little to show for it. With countless agencies promising to “10x your leads” or “increase your ROI,” how do you separate the hype from the truly helpful? Here’s a breakdown of what to look for when hiring an agency.

Clear Understanding of Your Goals

Before you even start your search, get crystal clear on what you want to achieve. Are you looking to increase website traffic? Improve conversion rates? Build brand awareness on social media? A great agency will ask the right questions to understand your business objectives and tailor their approach accordingly.

Red flag: If they push cookie-cutter packages without first learning about your business—walk away.

Proven Track Record

Experience matters. Ask about client testimonials, or success stories. Look for real results, not just metrics. A credible marketing agency should be proud to showcase their wins—and be transparent about their process.

Specialized Expertise

Digital marketing covers a wide spectrum—SEO, PPC, Social Media, email marketing, content strategy, AI search and more. Make sure the agency has expertise in the specific areas that matter most to your goals. You might not need everything, but you do want a team that knows its stuff.

Transparent Communication & Reporting

A good agency won’t keep you guessing. They’ll provide regular reports, clear metrics, and ongoing insights. You should always know where your money is going and what kind of return you’re getting.

Ask about:

• Reporting frequency

• Metrics they prioritize

• Tools they use for tracking and analytics

Strategic Thinking, Not Just Execution

You don’t just need someone to run ads or write blogs—you need a strategic partner. Look for an agency that thinks long-term, understands market trends, and offers proactive ideas to keep your brand ahead of the curve.

Realistic Promises

If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. Be wary of agencies that guarantee rankings, leads, or revenue. Digital marketing is powerful, but it’s not magic. A trustworthy marketing agency will set clear expectations, timelines, and deliverables—and keep it real.

Big Shark Marketing Digital Marketing Manager

Sarah Adkins is a digital marketing expert with over 25 years of experience in the industry. Based in Orlando, Florida, she has been at the forefront of online marketing & website design since 1999.

See Full Bio

Search Engine Optimization Paid Ads Management Social Media Marketing Website Design Content Writing